| Date | W/L | Score | Opponent | Round | Site |
| 5/9/1997 | Lost | 4-5 (9) | St. Mary's, MN | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/9/1997 | Lost | 0-3 | St. Thomas, MN | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/8/1998 | Won | 5-1 | North Central, IL | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/9/1998 | Lost | 3-4 | UW-Stevens Point | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/10/1998 | Won | 5-2 | North Central, IL | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/10/1998 | Won | 2-1 (10) | UW-Stevens Point | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/11/1998 | Lost | 3-6 | UW-Stevens Point | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/14/1999 | Won | 2-1 | UW-Stevens Point | Regionals | Whitewater |
| 5/15/1999 | Won | 8-0 (5) | Lawrence | Regionals | Whitewater |
| 5/15/1999 | Won | 4-3 | UW-Whitewater | Regionals | Whitewater |
| 5/20/1999 | Won | 4-0 | Alma, MI | Nationals | Eau Claire |
| 5/22/1999 | Lost | 0-5 (8) | Chapman, CA | Nationals | Eau Claire |
| 5/22/1999 | Won | 6-2 | Messiah, PA | Nationals | Eau Claire |
| 5/23/1999 | Lost | 3-4 | Alma, MI | Nationals | Eau Claire |
| Blugolds finished 4th at Nationals in 1999 | |||||
| 5/12/2000 | Won | 5-3 | St. Thomas, MN | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/13/2000 | Won | 2-1 | UW-Whitewater | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/14/2000 | Won | 3-1 | Simpson, IA | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/18/2000 | Lost | 0-3 | TCNJ | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| 5/19/2000 | Won | 4-1 (8) | Ithaca, NY | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| 5/20/2000 | Won | 3-2 (15) | Roanoke, VA | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| 5/20/2000 | Lost | 0-5 | Alma, MI | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| Blugolds finished 4th at Nationals in 2000 | |||||
| 5/11/2006 | Won | 2-1 (9) | Lake Forest, IL | Regionals | Rock Island, IL |
| 5/12/2006 | Won | 7-1 | Central, IA | Regionals | Rock Island, IL |
| 5/13/2006 | Won | 1-0 | Hope, MI | Regionals | Rock Island, IL |
| 5/15/2006 | Lost | 0-1 | Coe, IA | Regionals | Rock Island, IL |
| 5/15/2006 | Lost | 5-6 | Coe, IA | Regionals | Rock Island, IL |
| 5/10/2007 | Won | 6-3 | Augustana, IL | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/11/2007 | Won | 3-0 | Illinois Wesleyan | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/12/2007 | Won | 6-3 (8) | UW-Oshkosh | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/13/2007 | Won | 7-3 | UW-Oshkosh | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/18/2007 | Won | 9-1 (5) | Rhode Island | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| 5/19/2007 | Lost | 0-1 (8) | Washington, MO | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| 5/20/2007 | Won | 3-1 | Emory, GA | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| 5/20/2007 | Won | 6-5 | SUNY-Plattsburgh | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| 5/21/2007 | Lost | 10-22 (5) | Linfield, OR | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| Blugolds finished 3rd at Nationals in 2007 | |||||
| 5/8/2008 | Won | 10-0 (5) | North Central, IL | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/9/2008 | Won | 2-0 | UW-Oshkosh | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/10/2008 | Won | 5-4 (8) | St. Thomas, MN | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/11/2008 | Won | 6-0 | UW-Oshkosh | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/16/2008 | Won | 8-0 (6) | Ithaca, NY | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| 5/17/2008 | Won | 5-1 | Muskingum, OH | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| 5/18/2008 | Won | 2-1 | Louisiana College | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| 5/19/2008 | Won | 4-3 (9) | UW-Whitewater | Nationals | Salem, VA |
| Blugolds won National Title in 2008 | |||||
| 5/7/2009 | Lost | 1-4 | Coe, IA | Regionals | Bloomington, IL |
| 5/7/2009 | Won | 5-1 | UW-Whitewater | Regionals | Bloomington, IL |
| 5/9/2009 | Lost | 2-7 (9) | UW-Whitewater | Regionals | Bloomington, IL |
| 5/12/2011 | Lost | 3-9 | St. Thomas, MN | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/13/2011 | Lost | 1-4 | UW-River Falls | Regionals | Eau Claire |
| 5/10/2012 | Won | 6-1 | Fontbonne, MO | Regionals | Bloomington, IL |
| 5/11/2012 | Lost | 1-2 | Illinois Wesleyan | Regionals | Bloomington, IL |
| 5/12/2012 | Lost | 1-4 | Carthage College | Regionals | Bloomington, IL |
| 5/9/2013 | Lost | 10-12 | North Central, IL | Regionals | Whitewater |
| 5/10/2013 | Won | 5-1 | Benedictine, IL | Regionals | Whitewater |
| 5/11/2013 | Won | 4-0 | UW-Whitewater | Regionals | Whitewater |
| 5/11/2013 | Lost | 0-7 | Carthage College | Regionals | Whitewater |
| 5/9/19 | Won | 1-2 | Wartburg College (IA) | Regionals | St. Paul, MN |
| 5/10/19 | Lost | 0-1 | St. Thomas (MN) | Regionals | St. Paul, MN |
| 5/10/19 | Won | 4-3 | Wartburg College (IA) | Regionals | St. Paul, MN |
| 5/11/19 | Lost | 1-6 | St. Thomas (MN) | Regionals | St. Paul, MN |
| 5/13/22 | Lost | 0-3 | Trine (IN) | Regionals | Angola, IN |
| 5/14/22 | Won | 3-1 | Penn. St. - Behrend | Regionals | Angola, IN |
| 5/15/22 | Lost | 0-3 | North Central (IL) | Regionals | Angola, IN |
| 38-24 Record | 62 Total Games | ||||
Regionals Overall Record: 27-18 / Nationals Overall Record: 11-6
Page Last Updated: 5/16/2022