| Athlete | Year | Finish |
| Leslie Alm | 1968 | 2nd Team |
| Leslie Alm | 1969 | 2nd Team |
| Carl Bardenwerper | 1980 | HM |
| Carl Bardenwerper | 1981 | 1st Team |
| Steve Brunner | 1984 | 2nd Team |
| Scott Chapin | 1991 | 2nd Team |
| Tom Cheney | 1983 | 2nd Team |
| Tom Cheney | 1984 | 2nd Team |
| Tom Cheney | 1985 | 2nd Team |
| Matt Cooper | 2015 | HM |
| Matt Cyra | 2016 | 2nd Team |
| Paul Czech | 1984 | 2nd Team |
| Paul Czech | 1985 | 2nd Team |
| Jerry Danner | 1989 | 2nd Team |
| Connor Dolan | 2018 | HM |
| Connor Dolan | 2019 | 2nd Team |
| Connor Dolan | 2021 | 1st Team |
| Anthony Dupont | 2018 | 2nd Team |
| Aaron Easker | 2011 | HM |
| Aaron Easker | 2012 | 1st Team |
| Wyatt Elmer | 2018 | 2nd Team |
| Stephen Ertz | 1983 | HM |
| Jason Finch | 1996 | 2nd Team |
| Jason Finch | 1997 | 1st Team |
| Jason Finch | 1998 | 1st Team* |
| Jeff Fritsch | 1980 | HM |
| Dan Frusher | 1989 | 1st Team |
| Dan Frusher | 1991 | 1st Team |
| Tom Goetz | 1992 | 1st Team |
| Dave Griffiths | 1988 | 2nd Team |
| Brett Haffner | 2019 | HM |
| Kyle Hansen | 1997 | 2nd Team |
| Kyle Hansen | 1998 | 2nd Team |
| Dan Held | 1986 | 1st Team |
| Dan Held | 1987 | 1st Team |
| Dan Held | 1988 | 1st Team |
| Todd Herbert | 1976 | 2nd Team |
| Todd Herbert | 1977 | 1st Team |
| Todd Herbert | 1978 | 2nd Team |
| Paul Hetke | 2013 | HM |
| Mike Holzmann | 1985 | 2nd Team |
| Riley Huffman | 2016 | HM |
| Riley Huffman | 2017 | 2nd Team |
| Dan Kempf | 1987 | 2nd Team |
| Dan Kempf | 1989 | 2nd Team |
| Jeremy Kieser | 2010 | HM |
| Jeremy Kieser | 2012 | 2nd Team |
| Steve Kortenkamp | 1989 | 2nd Team |
| Sam Kuhlmann | 2016 | HM |
| Bill Langhout | 1979 | HM |
| James Larson | 2000 | 2nd Team |
| James Larson | 2001 | 2nd Team |
| Darin Lau | 2014 | 2nd Team |
| Darin Lau | 2015 | 1st Team |
| Darin Lau | 2016 | 1st Team |
| Darin Lau | 2017 | 1st Team* |
| Christian Leitner | 2013 | 2nd Team |
| Christian Leitner | 2014 | 1st Team |
| Christian Leitner | 2015 | 1st Team |
| Mike Monk | 1988 | 2nd Team |
| Mike Monk | 1989 | 1st Team |
| Ryan Mugan | 2013 | 1st Team |
| Ryan Mugan | 2014 | 1st Team |
| Ryan Mugan | 2015 | 1st Team |
| David Niedfeldt | 1991 | 2nd Team |
| Jon Novak | 1978 | 2nd Team |
| Jon Novak | 1979 | 1st Team |
| Jon Novak | 1980 | 1st Team |
| Dan Olson | 1987 | 2nd Team |
| Tyler Osen | 2021 | 2nd Team |
| Brendon Paucek | 2015 | HM |
| Bob Peterson | 1987 | 2nd Team |
| Bryan Peterson | 1978 | 2nd Team |
| Bryan Peterson | 1980 | 1st Team |
| Bryan Peterson | 1981 | 1st Team |
| Nick Petersson | 2013 | 2nd Team |
| Nick Petersson | 2016 | 1st Team |
| Dean Quigley | 1980 | 2nd Team |
| Conor Rafferty | 2011 | 2nd Team |
| Max Renner | 2010 | HM |
| Steve Rice | 1983 | HM |
| Erik Rosvold | 2014 | HM |
| Aric Runzheimer | 2010 | 2nd Team |
| Aaron Scheller | 1993 | 2nd Team |
| Aaron Scheller | 1995 | 2nd Team |
| Steven Schimmel | 2014 | HM |
| Dave Schroeder | 1975 | 2nd Team |
| Dave Schroeder | 1976 | 2nd Team |
| Dick Schuh | 1972 | 2nd Team |
| Kelly Schuller | 1986 | 2nd Team |
| Matt Scott | 2013 | 1st Team |
| Mason Shea | 2022 | HM |
| Jim Spiegelberg | 1978 | 2nd Team |
| Jim Spiegelberg | 1979 | HM |
| Dan Stack | 1980 | 1st Team* |
| Dan Stack | 1981 | 1st Team* |
| John Stintzi | 1976 | 2nd Team |
| John Stintzi | 1978 | 1st Team |
| Travis Thiel | 1995 | 2nd Team |
| Travis Thiel | 1996 | 2nd Team |
| Josh Thorson | 2014 | 1st Team* |
| Josh Thorson | 2015 | 1st Team |
| Dave Tomten | 1977 | 2nd Team |
| Dave Tomten | 1979 | HM |
| Patrick Treacy | 2016 | 2nd Team |
| Patrick Treacy | 2018 | 1st Team |
| John Vodacek | 1976 | 2nd Team |
| John Vodacek | 1977 | 1st Team |
| Alex Winn | 2019 | HM |
During the 1981-1983 seasons, places 1-10 received 1st Team, 11-20 receieved Honorable Mention
Beginning in the 1984 season, places 1-10 recieved 1st Team, 11-20 recieved 2nd Team
More recently, places 1-7 receive 1st Team honors, while places 8-14 are named to the 2nd Team, 15-20 are Honorable Mention
Conference Champion = *
Updated: 1/26/23