| Athlete | Year | Finish |
| Mel Becker | 2017 | 26th, 21:23 (NCAA) |
| Brenda Bergum | 1984 | 22nd, 18:27 (NAIA) |
| Brenda Bergum | 1985 | 12th, 19:24 (NAIA) |
| Brenda Bergum | 1986 | 10th, 18:30 (NAIA) |
| Julie Cotter | 1992 | 21st, 19:43 (NAIA) |
| Jen Deitte | 1997 | 33rd, 19:17 (NCAA) |
| Karin Diestelmeier | 2000 | 15th, 18:26.7 (NCAA) |
| Callie Fischer | 2017 | 35th, 21:33 (NCAA) |
| Chris Goepel | 1984 | 8th, 18:06 (NAIA) |
| Chris Goepel | 1985 | 5th, 19:08 (NAIA) |
| Margaret Ho | 2009 | 33rd, 22:50.5 (NCAA) |
| Margaret Ho | 2010 | 22nd, 21:38.9 (NCAA) |
| Jennifer Kinlund | 1997 | 35th, 19:18 (NCAA) |
| Beth Lutz | 2007 | 29th, 22:03 (NCAA) |
| Deanna Marchello (Vodacek) | 1981 | 15th, 19:33 (AIAW) |
| Deanna Marchello (Vodacek) | 1982 | 2nd, 17:53 (NAIA) |
| Deanna Marchello (Vodacek) | 1983 | 5th, 18:00 (NAIA) |
| Morgan Marek | 2018 | 28th, 2148.6 (NCAA) |
| Ashlyn Mauer | 2012 | 6th, 21:21.8 (NCAA) |
| Angie Molter | 1991 | 29th, 18:57 (NAIA) |
| Mary Palmer | 2008 | 26th, 21:34.82 (NCAA) |
| Elly Prunty | 2010 | 17th, 21:34.1 (NCAA) |
| Lucy Ramquist | 2015 | 8th, 21:33 (NCAA) |
| Madi Sawyer | 2012 | 30th, 21:54.3 (NCAA) |
| Carolyn Sheild | 1982 | 3rd, 17:56 (NAIA) |
| Carolyn Sheild | 1983 | 14th, 18:35 (NAIA) |
| Sam Slattery | 2017 | 17th, 21:08 (NCAA) |
| Katie Somers-Steinkopf | 1984 | 1st, 17:36 (NAIA) |
| Alyssa Sybilrud | 2009 | 21st, 22:36.2 (NCAA) |
| Alyssa Sybilrud | 2010 | 23rd, 21:39.1 (NCAA) |
| Lexie Tremble | 2019 | 35th, 22:09.4 (NCAA) |
| Laura Wodyn (Ecker) | 1985 | 10th, 19:20 (NAIA) |
Became member of NCAA III in 1993. No All-Americans in 1993-95
AIAW All-Americans were Top 15.
NAIA All-Americans were Top 25 until 1991 when changed to Top 30.
NCAA III All-Americans were Top 25 until 1994 when changed to Top 35.
Page Last Updated: 9/21/20