| Athlete | Year | Finish |
| Dan Stack | 1980 | 22nd, 25:16 (NAIA) |
| Dan Held | 1987 | 10th, 24:46 (NAIA) |
| Dan Held | 1988 | 16th, 25:09 (NAIA) |
| Tom Goetz | 1992 | 20th, 26:43 (NAIA) |
| Jason Finch | 1998 | 6th, 25:19 (NCAA) |
| Aaron Easker | 2012 | 27th, 25:02 (NCAA) |
| Jeremy Kieser | 2012 | 15th, 24:50 (NCAA) |
| Ryan Mugan | 2013 | 13th, 25:03 (NCAA) |
| Ryan Mugan | 2014 | 10th, 24:09 (NCAA) |
| Darin Lau | 2014 | 31st, 24:35 (NCAA) |
| Josh Thorson | 2014 | 3rd, 23:57 (NCAA) |
| Josh Thorson | 2015 | 2nd, 24:15 (NCAA) |
| Ryan Mugan | 2015 | 11th, 24:36 (NCAA) |
| Darin Lau | 2015 | 14th, 24:42 (NCAA) |
| Darin Lau | 2016 | 6th, 24:22 (NCAA) |
| Nick Petersson | 2016 | 31st, 24:52 (NCAA) |
| Patrick Treacy | 2016 | 34th, 24:54 (NCAA) |
| Darin Lau | 2017 | 1st, 24:03 (NCAA) |
| Connor Dolan | 2019 | 39th, 24:56 (NCAA) |
Became member of NCAA III in 1993. No All-Americans in 1993-95
NAIA All-Americans were Top 25 until 1991 when changed to Top 30.
NCAA III All-Americans were Top 25 until 1994 when changed to Top 35.
Page Last Updated: 4/10/20