Wrestling All-Americans
| Name | Year | Weight | Place | Affiliation |
| Mark Janicki | 1969 | 145 | 3rd | NAIA |
| Mark Janicki | 1970 | 150 | 4th | NAIA |
| Tony Algiers | 1982 | 134 | 4th | NAIA |
| Bob Wozniak | 1988 | 190 | 4th | NAIA |
| Bob Wozniak | 1989 | 190 | 4th | NAIA |
| Bob Wozniak | 1990 | 190 | 2nd | NAIA |
| Joe Bethea | 1990 | Hwt | 5th | NAIA |
| Davey Starks | 2002 | 125 | 7th | NCAA |
| Adam Kolo | 2003 | 197 | 5th | NCAA |
| Derek Sikora | 2004 | 165 | 3rd | NCAA |
| Derek Sikora | 2005 | 165 | 5th | NCAA |
| Derek Sikora | 2006 | 165 | 1st | NCAA |
| Josh Holforty | 2008 | 197 | 6th | NCAA |
| Josh Holforty | 2009 | 197 | 3rd | NCAA |
| Nathaniel Behnke | 2013 | 141 | 5th | NCAA |
| Nathaniel Behnke | 2016 | 141 | 3rd | NCAA |
| Jake Drexler | 2020 | 149 | N/A (Championships canceled) | NCAA |
| Evan Lawrence | 2020 | 174 | N/A (Championships canceled) | NCAA |
| Noah Carter | 2020 | 285 | N/A (Championships canceled) | NCAA |
| Chase Schmidt | 2022 | 165 | 3rd | NCAA |
| Tyler Fleetwood | 2023 | 133 | 3rd | NCAA |
| Jared Stricker | 2023 | 174 | 2nd | NCAA |