| Mark Janicki |
1969 |
145 |
3rd |
NAIA |
| Mark Janicki |
1970 |
150 |
4th |
NAIA |
| Tony Algiers |
1982 |
134 |
4th |
NAIA |
| Bob Wozniak |
1988 |
190 |
4th |
NAIA |
| Bob Wozniak |
1989 |
190 |
4th |
NAIA |
| Bob Wozniak |
1990 |
190 |
2nd |
NAIA |
| Joe Bethea |
1990 |
Hwt |
5th |
NAIA |
| Davey Starks |
2002 |
125 |
7th |
NCAA |
| Adam Kolo |
2003 |
197 |
5th |
NCAA |
| Derek Sikora |
2004 |
165 |
3rd |
NCAA |
| Derek Sikora |
2005 |
165 |
5th |
NCAA |
| Derek Sikora |
2006 |
165 |
1st |
NCAA |
| Josh Holforty |
2008 |
197 |
6th |
NCAA |
| Josh Holforty |
2009 |
197 |
3rd |
NCAA |
| Nathaniel Behnke |
2013 |
141 |
5th |
NCAA |
| Nathaniel Behnke |
2016 |
141 |
3rd |
NCAA |
| Jake Drexler |
2020 |
149 |
N/A (Championships canceled) |
NCAA |
| Evan Lawrence |
2020 |
174 |
N/A (Championships canceled) |
NCAA |
| Noah Carter |
2020 |
285 |
N/A (Championships canceled) |
NCAA |
| Chase Schmidt |
2022 |
165 |
3rd |
NCAA |
| Tyler Fleetwood |
2023 |
133 |
3rd |
NCAA |
| Jared Stricker |
2023 |
174 |
2nd |
NCAA |