Football - All-Americans
| Athlete | Season | Organization | Team | Notes |
| Wil Beech | 1986 | NAIA | 2nd Team | OT |
| Wil Beech | 1987 | NAIA | 1st Team | OG |
| Mike Bestul | 2002 | FB Gazette | 3rd Team | OL |
| Luke Burger | 1998 | FB Gazette | 1st Team | OT |
| Austin Crow | 2001 | D3football.com | HM | DE |
| Chad Hoiska | 1997 | USA FB | 1st Team | RB |
| Chad Hoiska | 1997 | FB Gazette | 3rd Team | RB |
| Jay Hoyord | 2001 | Hewlett-Packard | 2nd Team | S |
| Jay Hoyord | 2001 | FB Gazette | 3rd Team | S |
| Clay Iverson | 1998 | FB Gazette | 1st Team | OT |
| Chad Ludescher | 1998 | FB Gazette | 1st Team | LB |
| Mike March | 1981 | NAIA | 1st Team | DB |
| Mike March | 1982 | NAIA | 2nd Team | DB |
| Dan McCarty | 1997 | USA FB | 2nd Team | TE |
| Dan McCarty | 1997 | FB Gazette | 3rd Team | TE |
| Mike Molnar | 1984 | NAIA | 2nd Team | OT |
| Brad Newton | 2001 | FB Gazette | HM | TE |
| Brad Newton | 2002 | FB Gazette | 3rd Team | TE |
| Mitch Patri | 1978 | NAIA | 2nd Team | OT |
| Don Pierce | 1956 | NAIA | 2nd Team | OT |
| Sam Romanski | 2018 | AP | 2nd Team | LB |
| Sam Romanski | 2018 | D3football.com | 2nd Team | LB |
| Paul Santi | 2013 | D3football.com | HM | C |
| Tom Saskowski | 1984 | NAIA | 2nd Team | TE |
| Bob Schmidt | 2000 | USA FB | 2nd Team | OT |
| Bob Schmidt | 2000 | D3football.com | HM | OT |
| Bob Schmidt | 2001 | D3football.com | 2nd Team | OT |
| Bob Schmidt | 2001 | FB Gazette | 3rd Team | OT |
| Darrell Souhrada | 2000 | USA FB | 2nd Team | RB |
| Brent Tieri | 2005 | D3football.com | 3rd Team | S |
| Jim Van Gorden | 1964 | NAIA | 1st Team | QB |
| Roger Vann | 1981 | NAIA | 1st Team | RB |
| Lee Weigel | 1984 | NAIA | 1st Team | RB |
| Lee Weigel | 1985 | NAIA | 1st Team | RB |
| John White | 1979 | NAIA | 2nd Team | DE |
| Dave Wicklund | 2007 | D3football.com | 3rd Team | S |
| Jeff Wilson | 1983 | NAIA | 1st Team | OT |